Why are there
advertisements
on this page?

 
Trans4mind Network
Trans4mind - Personal Development Resources
Tools for Transformation
HU Személyiségfejlesztés IT Sviluppo Personale ES Dessarollo Personal
FR Épanouissement Personel DE Persönlichkeitsentwicklung اللغة العربية
 
E X P L O R E   T H E S E   L I F E   C H A L L E N G E S . . .
 
T H E    W O R L D' S    P R E M I E R    P E R S O N A L    D E V E L O P M E N T    W E B S I T E
Centerpointe Research Institute
Amazing health benefits as well as profound emotional relief. Learn more...

Counterpoint - The Personal Development Article Library


Serious Problems in Psychotherapy Require Serious Medicine

By Steven A. Frankel, M.D.

Suggest this page to a friend
print Print-friendly version

As a psychotherapy patient, do you wonder whether the work you and your therapist are doing will succeed and produce lasting results? You may like, even admire, your psychotherapist, but how do you know that as a result of his or her work you will achieve the goals for which you came to treatment?

Patients frequently remain in the dark about whether treatment is actually succeeding. The solution to this dilemma is a treatment considerably broader in scope than conventional psychological and psychiatric therapy. This treatment embodies proven techniques for accurately assessing the nature and severity of a psychological problem and for monitoring treatment progress. In using these methods, therapist and patient work collaboratively to track progress, continually providing feedback to each other.

In conducting this innovative method of treatment, the therapist assumes the kind of clinical responsibility that is typical of a physician. He or she takes responsibility for addressing the full range of the patient's presenting and underlying problems, and coordinating his or her treatment, always assimilating the feedback the patient provides.

Take my patient Cori (not her real name). She had been treated by multiple psychotherapists and psychopharmacologists. Cori was bright and empathic, but had a history of failed relationships, depression, and withdrawal when situations soured. Following the loss of a job, Cori was forced to seek support from her aging parents.

All previous attempts at treating Cori had been disappointing. The medications prescribed by Cori's psychiatrists and psychopharmacologists all created additional problems through their side effects. Psychotherapy was unsatisfactory, too. In part, what caused these failures was the inability of professionals to work closely together. Those who were medically oriented also neglected to take full account of Cori's feelings of disappointment and helplessness, while they focused on her physiology. Cori fired her last therapist after two years because she had not progressed. That was when Cori first came to me.

Cori's case was indeed challenging. She needed a full medication review and overhaul, a more functional support system, vocational retraining, and goal-oriented psychotherapy addressing not only her depression, but also practical problems interfering with her daily life. No single issue had overriding priority, and none could be resolved with conventional psychotherapy alone.

What Cori required was a new kind of approach to her treatment, one distinguished by reliable diagnostic assessment, clear-cut goals, monitoring of progress, and above all, coordination between professionals. This is the approach I use when practicing collaborative psychology. As therapist-coordinator of Cori's case, I orchestrate and monitor the entire operation, collaborating with all the other clinicians and consultants involved, and the key people in her support system. But, this brief description of my experience with Cori doesn't capture the essence of the treatment. Cori was a complex human being and this new treatment had to be characterized by profound respect for her and her thinking. Cori needed to be a fully collaborating partner in her treatment. A patient, but not just a patient.

In its comprehensiveness and use of psychological assessment, this is a novel approach to psychotherapy. When patients have a combination of symptoms, such as depression, difficulties involving family, children, relationships, or employment, and at times one or more medical conditions, the issues tend to overlap and may be hard to sort out. To find solutions to these complex problems, the therapist must closely collaborate with the patient and all the other professionals involved.

At the beginning of collaborative psychology treatment there is a clinical evaluation. This step is followed as soon as possible by psychological or neuropsychological testing. Based on these two assessments and the data they provide, the therapist-coordinator prepares a preliminary treatment plan. At this point the patient and therapist together determine the type of treatment they are agreeing to undertake. Then each clinical strategy proposed in the treatment plan is evaluated for efficacy during a trial period. Verbal or written reports, successively modifying the treatment plan, are created in response to changes and progress in treatment.

You may be asking yourself at this point why go to this much trouble and expense?

Consider for a moment the world of medicine. Would you fault a physician who is meticulous about collecting data, obtains needed consultations, regularly informs patients about findings, and revises his or her treatment plan according to whether or not progress is occurring? Of course not.

Using this collaborative psychology method, clinician and patient can determine exactly what kinds of problems need to be treated and become aware of changes in the patient's status as they occur. As the patient or his or her circumstances change, the treatment plan can be modified, so it remains maximally effective. A second clinical and data-based opinion from the psychologist who administers the assessment tests is always part of the process. This person remains available throughout treatment and even past its termination.  Making the clinical process even stronger are the regular progress reports the patient receives from and discusses with the clinician.

The extra cost and time required for this comprehensive treatment approach are more than justified by its built in focus on the patient's progressively demonstrated needs and progress. The testing and self-discipline this procedure requires of the clinician assures against misdiagnosis or over-treatment. The likelihood of engaging in formulaic, unproductive treatment, such as often occurs when a therapist reflexively sees a psychotherapy patient once per week for many months or even years, is much reduced. Collaboration with spouses or family members is also encouraged when it is likely improve the treatment outcome.

And, once again, the benefits of such a process? More focused and efficient treatment that leads to substantial results. Cori is now working at a job she enjoys, her family is actively supporting her recovery, she hasn't abused any substances for several years, and is doing a marvelous job of mothering her two boys. Those are results!  

Steven A. Frankel, M.D. is the author of four books describing collaborative psychology, including his most recent book Evidence from Within: A Paradigm for Clinical Practice. He has been a practicing psychiatrist for over thirty years. A graduate of Yale University Medical School, Dr. Frankel is board certified in both general and child psychiatry. He is an Associate Clinical Professor at the University of California Medical School and founder and director of the Center for Collaborative Psychology in Kentfield, CA. Learn more about how you, your family, or your patients can work with Dr. Frankel at Steven A. Frankel, M.D..
 
 

Learn Out Loud
You'll find the Cultivate Life! Podcast at LearnOutLoud.com - your one-stop destination for audio and video learning. Browse over 15,000 educational audio books, MP3 downloads, podcasts, and videos.

goldline.gif
Daring to be Yourself
Daring to be Yourself The aim of the new book, Daring to be Yourself by Peter Shepherd, is to help you achieve a 'wide-awake' state of consciousness, with integrated use of left and right brain abilities, forming the bedrock for breakthroughs in personal consciousness and spiritual insight. The practice is based on the premise that we have learned disabilities that set boundaries to our action and knowing. But no one need accept that they must remain as they were shaped by their hereditary body-mind and by the conditioning of their childhood and culture.
gap
This 264-page, $8.95 digital eBook is like a "best of" the Trans4mind site, all brought together for your convenience. But much more than that, it's also an incredibly powerful program for personal growth. Remove the barriers to self-knowledge and reveal your full potential with this step-by-step approach... Daring to be Yourself
gap
Our Blog features excerpts from the book plus current news, views and links.
"I realize many people use praise in ways that sound frivolous...but I must tell you that your book has changed my life AND I mean that in all ways. I found the entire work wonderfully upbeat, readable and valuable! It really was quite a wakeup call. In the midst of my "trials and tribulations" I had failed to be "me." Anyway, this "talk with you" really did change my life. Thank you! I needed this kind of "kick in the pants." It worked. WOW! You made a huge difference in my world."–Becky, USA

Begin your life afresh... A digital copy of Daring to be Yourself is included with purchase of the Start a New Life! home-study course - which is effectively the practical "workbook" that accompanies the book by Peter Shepherd.

Working through this course enables you to dare to be yourself and design a brand new life. Expressing your true needs, wants and feelings, you can start to live your life's purpose!

After you have purchased the course, Peter Shepherd is available whenever you wish by email, to guide you every step of the way from where you are now, until you are established in a brand new life - the life that you have designed... Start a New Life!

goldline.gif

The Holosync SolutionTM
  • Have you been searching for a personal growth and mind development program that really works?
  • Are you tired of approaches that promise a lot... only to find that they don't create any real and lasting changes for you?
  • Do you feel ready right now to begin dramatically accelerating your mental, emotional and spiritual growth?

If so, then click here now...

Life Quality Enhancement

More information | Click here to order

  Hypnosis Downloads  |  Learn Hypnosis Online - Free Audio Course!  |  What is Hypnosis?
Hypnosis Downloads: Click for more information...
Download Learn hypnosis Listen and Relax
 
Self Improvement
Persevere & Never Give Up
Happiness in Motherhood
Be Able to Save Money
Overcome Stage Fright
Care Less What Others Think
Boost Your Confidence
Increase Self Esteem
Develop Optimism
Cool Down Blushing
Overcoming Insecurity
Stop Negative Thinking
Overcome Writers Block
Developing Powerful Optimism
Conversation Starter
Stop Self-Sabotage
Weight Loss
Lose Weight-Eat Healthily
Think Thin
Lose Your Sweet Tooth
Comfort Eating
Banish Fast Food
Weight Loss Motivation
Health
Exercise Motivation
Healing Power
Smoking - Stay Quit
Ease Migraine Headaches
No More Tension Headaches
Stop Using Marijuana
Irritable Bowel Syndrome
Chocolate Addiction
Chronic Pain Management
Reduce Pain in Childbirth
Overcome Caffeine Addiction
Lower Your Blood Pressure
Hangover Cure
No More Morning Sickness
 
Personal Development
Improve Concentration & Focus
Believe in Yourself
Fear of Interviews
Self Motivation Booster
Public Speaking Confidence
Best Man's Speech
Improve Your Concentration
Creativity Booster
Increase Emotional Intelligence
Achieve Your Potential
No More Procrastination!
Motivation & Energy at Work
Creative Problem Solving
Language Learning
Inspirational Lives
Brain Power & Creativity
Mental Toughness in Sports
Quick off the Blocks
 
Fears and Phobias
Overcome Fear of Death
Fear of Rejection
Fear of Crowds
Fear of Confrontation
Fear of Failure
Stop Panic Attacks
Fear of Flying
Fear of Elevators
Unfamiliar Surroundings
Social Phobia
Fear of Dentists
Overcome Anxiety
Fear of Heights
Driving Test Nerves
Exam Nerves
Fear of Birds
Overcome Hospital Phobia
Overcome Needle Phobia
Fear of Spiders
Fear of Driving
Fear of Success
Overcome Snake Phobia
Fear of Bridges
Fear of Water
Fear of the Dark
Wedding Nerves
Performance Anxiety
Overcome Claustrophobia
Sexual Performance Anxiety
Fear of Dogs
Fear of Being Alone

Full CD Programs
Click here for details of these great in-depth programs

What's New?
Click here to discover the latest ... maybe just what you need!
 
Treatment for Depression
Fast and effective! The most powerful self-help tool available today for depression

Hypnotherapy
Cure Insomnia
Manage Your Anger
Stop Premature Ejaculation
Dealing with Guilt
Dealing with Grief
Overcome Impotence
Cure Nail Biting
Your Troubled Childhood
Fear of Illness
Stuttering Therapy
Overcome Road Rage
Stop Bed Wetting
Hair Pulling
Teeth Grinding
Shopping Addiction
Alcohol Withdrawal
Stay Off Alcohol
Overcome Alcohol Abuse
Midlife Crisis
Dealing with Job Loss
Manage Stress
Beat Burn Out
Get an Energy Booster
Relieve Stress and Tension
Feel Better Now!
Learn Stress Management
Instant Stress Relief
Relaxation
A Healthy Rest
The Four Seasons
The Island
Guided Meditation
Fall Asleep Fast
 
Experience powerful hypnosis from the privacy of your own computer

Free sample downloads: Check out the new blog and podcasts!